The first thing to unlearn
A reader who grew up with the idea of heaven and hell as it is taught in many other religions brings an assumption to this subject without noticing it: that these are final. You live once, you are judged, and you go to one or the other for ever.
Sanatana Dharma has a heaven, , and it has hells, the . But in it neither is final. Both are places one passes through.
The reason follows directly from what karma is. A finite action has a finite result. Good deeds lay up merit, , and wrong deeds lay up demerit, . Heaven is where a large store of merit is enjoyed. Enjoying it uses it up. When it is gone, the stay is over.
The Bhagavad Gita says so in plain words, speaking of those who perform the Vedic rites in the hope of heaven:
Having enjoyed the wide world of heaven, when their merit is exhausted they enter the world of mortals. Following the way of the three Vedas, desiring objects of desire, they obtain only a going and a coming back.
The same holds, in mirror image, for the hells. Suffering there exhausts demerit, and then that too is over.
The lamp in the picture is this site's own illustration, not a traditional one, but it holds the idea well. A lamp does not go out as a punishment. It goes out because the oil is finite.
The Gita draws the largest conclusion a little earlier: Even the highest heaven is inside the circle.
A cosmos with many storeys
Heaven and the hells are only two regions in a much larger picture. The Puranas describe the universe as a vertical arrangement of fourteen worlds, or : seven rising from the earth upward, and seven below it.
The seven upper worlds begin with our own, Bhu, the earth. Above it are Bhuvar, the atmosphere, and Svar, which is heaven proper, the realm of Indra and the gods. These three are the "three worlds" named at the start of the Gayatri mantra, bhur bhuvah svah. Above them rise Mahar, Jana, Tapa and Satya, the worlds of sages and of the creator. The highest, Satya, is also called .
The seven lower worlds are the surprise. A reader expects them to be hells, and they are nothing of the kind. They are the realms of the nagas, and of the daityas and danavas, the ancient rivals of the gods. The hells are described separately, as a region of their own, placed below or to the south.
One feature of this picture deserves attention. The earth is called the field of action. It is in a human life that new karma is made and that liberation can be sought. In the worlds above and below, beings mostly live out the results of what they did here. For this reason the texts repeatedly call a human birth precious and hard to obtain, and say that even the gods must be born as humans to become free.
Yama
Presiding over the passage of the dead is , and his story changed over time.
In the Rig Veda he is not a figure of dread. In later literature he becomes Dharmaraja, the king of justice, who weighs the deeds of the dead and sends each onward according to what they have done. The Puranas give him an assistant, Chitragupta, a scribe who keeps the record of every person's actions.
It is worth recalling from Lesson 7 how the philosophical schools understood this. The record-keeper is a picture. On their account what determines a person's next state is the person's own karma, and Yama does not decide anything that the deeds have not already decided. And as the last lesson showed, this same Yama is the patient teacher of the Katha Upanishad, who tells a boy the secret of the deathless Self.
The two paths after death
Long before the Puranas mapped the worlds, the Upanishads gave their own account of what happens after death, and they framed it as two roads.
Perspectives
The two paths
As taught in the Chandogya and Brihadaranyaka Upanishads.
Devayana
The path of the gods
For those who have knowledge, and who live in the forest in faith and austerity. They pass into the flame, from the flame into the day, into the bright fortnight, into the six months when the sun moves north, and onward through the sun and the lightning to the world of Brahman. For them there is no return.
Source: Chandogya Upanishad 5.10.1-2; Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 6.2.15
Pitriyana
The path of the ancestors
For those who live in villages, performing rites and giving gifts. They pass into the smoke, into the night, into the dark fortnight, into the six months when the sun moves south, and so to the moon. There they stay as long as their merit lasts. Then they return by the same way: into space, wind, cloud and rain, into plants and food, and so into a new birth, fitted to their past conduct.
Source: Chandogya Upanishad 5.10.3-7; Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 6.2.16
The leads out of the cycle. The is the Upanishadic form of exactly what the Gita verse describes: up to a heaven, and back down.
The stations on these roads, flame and smoke, the waxing and waning moon, are a language of light and darkness. The commentators read them as presiding powers that conduct the soul onward, not as dates on which it is lucky or unlucky to die.
The narakas
The hells are described most fully in the Puranas, and above all in the Garuda Purana, which is traditionally recited in many communities during the days of mourning after a death.
The numbers differ from text to text. Each is matched to a kind of wrongdoing, and the principle of the match is nearly always that the suffering mirrors the act. One who was cruel to living creatures meets that cruelty; one who robbed others is robbed of everything; one who deceived is lost in darkness. The texts dwell on these scenes at length and in harsh detail, which this site does not reproduce.
What matters for understanding them is that every stay is temporary, and that it is followed by rebirth. How literally the descriptions should be taken is a question on which Hindus have held different views.
Perspectives
How the hells have been read
Three readings, all of them found within the tradition.
As places
The plain reading of the Puranas, and the belief of many Hindus through history: the narakas are real regions where real consequences are met, as real as this world is.
As teaching
The descriptions exist to turn people away from harm. Vivid pictures of consequences do what an abstract statement of the law of karma cannot. On this reading their purpose is moral, and their details are means to that end.
As states of mind
Heaven and hell describe conditions of the mind, experienced here as much as hereafter. A mind full of hatred is already in a hell of its own making. Many modern teachers favour this reading.
The readings do not exclude one another, and a single person may hold more than one. The historian of religion Knut Jacobsen has pointed out that, vivid as it is, hell has a limited place in Hindu thought as a whole: the aim the tradition sets before a person is not to avoid hell but to be free of rebirth altogether.
Beyond every world
That brings us back to where the lesson began. If heaven is temporary, heaven cannot be the goal.
This is perhaps the most distinctive feature of the whole picture. In the Katha Upanishad the boy Nachiketa is offered all the pleasures of heaven and refuses them, because they "last only until tomorrow". The seeker in this tradition is asked to see even the highest heaven as a comfortable waiting room, and to want something else: , which is not a place within the cosmos at all.
Heaven is earned and therefore spent. Moksha, as the last lessons explained, is not earned. It is the recognition of what one already is, or in the devotional schools the gift of the Lord, and so there is nothing in it that can run out.
A note of comparison
It may help to set this beside the more widely known picture, with respect for both.
In the mainstream teaching of Christianity and of Islam, a person lives one life. It is followed by judgment, and by a heaven or a hell that is everlasting. The moral weight of that single life is therefore immense, and the mercy of God in the face of it is central to both faiths. Within each there are also other voices: Catholic teaching includes a purgatory that purifies and ends, and thinkers in both traditions have hoped or argued that hell will not last for ever.
The Hindu picture distributes the weight differently. No single life is the last word, no state within the cosmos is permanent, and the final goal lies outside the scheme of reward and punishment altogether. Buddhism and Jainism, which grew in the same soil, share the temporary heavens and hells while differing on what liberation is.
Neither picture is offered here as better. They are different answers to the same human questions about justice, mercy and what finally becomes of us.
In short
Key takeaways
- Svarga and the narakas are temporary. Merit and demerit are finite, and when they are used up the soul returns to birth (Bhagavad Gita 9.20-21).
- The Puranas describe fourteen worlds, seven upper and seven lower. The lower worlds are splendid realms, not hells, and their names differ between texts.
- Yama is king of the ancestors in the Rig Veda and judge of the dead in later texts. What decides a person's course is their own karma.
- The Upanishads teach two paths after death: the path of the gods, without return, and the path of the ancestors, which leads to the moon and back to birth.
- The hells are described vividly in the Puranas and have been read literally, as moral teaching, and as states of mind.
- Moksha lies beyond all the worlds, the highest heaven included.
Sources
References
Primary texts
- Bhagavad Gita 8.16, 8.23-26, 9.20-21, 15.6.
- Chandogya Upanishad 5.10; Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 6.2.15-16; Mundaka Upanishad 1.2.10; Katha Upanishad 1.1.26. Translation: Patrick Olivelle, The Early Upanishads: Annotated Text and Translation (Oxford University Press, 1998).
- Rig Veda 10.14. Translation: Stephanie W. Jamison and Joel P. Brereton, The Rigveda: The Earliest Religious Poetry of India (Oxford University Press, 2014).
- Vishnu Purana 2.5-6. Translation: H. H. Wilson, The Vishnu Purana: A System of Hindu Mythology and Tradition (John Murray, 1840).
- Bhagavata Purana 5.24-26. Translation: G. V. Tagare, The Bhagavata Purana, Ancient Indian Tradition and Mythology series (Motilal Banarsidass, 1976).
- Garuda Purana (Saroddhara). Translation: Ernest Wood and S. V. Subrahmanyam, The Garuda Purana (Saroddhara), Sacred Books of the Hindus, vol. 9 (Allahabad, 1911).
- Manusmriti 4.88-90. Translation: Patrick Olivelle, Manu's Code of Law (Oxford University Press, 2005).
Studies
- Knut A. Jacobsen, "Three Functions of Hell in the Hindu Traditions", Numen 56 (2009), pp. 385-400.
- Wendy Doniger O'Flaherty (ed.), Karma and Rebirth in Classical Indian Traditions (University of California Press, 1980).
- P. V. Kane, History of Dharmashastra, vol. 4 (Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute, 1953), on the hells and the rites for the dead.
- Gavin Flood, An Introduction to Hinduism (Cambridge University Press, 1996), chapters 4 and 5.
