Skip to content
Ekam Sat

Section III: Core Ideas

Atman and Brahman

The central insight of the Upanishads, and how three schools read it.

Two questions

The Upanishads keep returning to two questions, and at first they look unrelated.

The first looks outward. What is this world, at bottom? Behind all the changing things, is there something that does not change, from which they come and into which they return? The Upanishads call that .

The second looks inward. What am I? Not my name or my job, and not my body, which was a child's body once and is a different body now. When everything about me that changes is set aside, what is left? The Upanishads call that , the Self.

The discovery for which the Upanishads are known is that these two questions have one answer.

Brahman: the ground of everything

The word Brahman comes from a root meaning "to grow" or "to expand". In the hymns it meant the sacred power of the Vedic word. In the Upanishads it comes to mean the reality that underlies the whole universe.

One Upanishad defines it by what it does: "That from which these beings are born, by which, once born, they live, and into which they enter when they pass away: seek to know that. That is Brahman." Taittiriya Upanishad 3.1 Another describes it in three words: reality, knowledge, the infinite. Taittiriya Upanishad 2.1

Brahman is not a god among the gods, and the word should not be confused with Brahma, the creator deity, or with brahmin, the priestly class. Whether Brahman is to be understood as a personal Lord with qualities, or as a reality beyond all qualities, is a question on which the schools divide, as we shall see.

Atman: the one who knows

Now turn inward. Try to find yourself.

You are aware of your body, so in some sense you stand apart from it as its observer. You are aware of your thoughts as they come and go, and of your moods, so the same is true of them. Whatever you can observe is, by that fact, an object to you, and you are the one to whom it appears. The Upanishads follow this line until every object has been set aside, and they call what remains the Atman.

"You cannot see the seer of seeing," the sage Yajnavalkya says. "You cannot hear the hearer of hearing, you cannot think the thinker of thinking. This Self of yours is within all." Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 3.4.2 The eye cannot see itself. In the same way, the Self cannot be made into one more object of knowledge, because it is what does the knowing.

This is why the same sage describes it only by negation: , "not this, not this". Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 2.3.6 It is not a refusal to answer. Whatever you can point to and call "this" is, for that reason, not the one pointing.

The great sayings

Then comes the step that makes the Upanishads what they are. The unchanging ground of the world and the unchanging witness within are declared to be the same.

Four short sentences, one from each Veda, are traditionally singled out as stating this. They are called the , the "great sayings".

"Consciousness is Brahman", from the Rig Veda. "I am Brahman", from the Yajur Veda. "You are that", from the Sama Veda. "This Self is Brahman", from the Atharva Veda.

A statement this large is easy to repeat and hard to understand, so the Upanishads and their teachers explain it with pictures taken from ordinary life. Here are three of the most famous.

Salt in water

In the Chandogya Upanishad a father, Uddalaka, is teaching his son Shvetaketu, who has come home from twelve years of study rather proud of his learning. The father teaches by experiment.

Loading the diagram

What does the experiment show? That something can be really present throughout a thing and still not be visible in it. The boy could not find the salt by looking. He found it by another means, tasting, and found it everywhere. Brahman, the father is saying, is like that. Do not expect to see it as one object among others. It is present through all of them.

The space in the pot

The second picture comes from Gaudapada, the teacher of Shankara's teacher, and it addresses the obvious objection. If the Self is one, why does it seem that there are billions of separate selves, one to each body?

Consider a clay pot. There is space inside it. We speak of "the space in this pot" as though it were a separate thing, and it even seems to have properties: it is small, it is round, it can be carried to the next room.

Loading the diagram

"The Self is like space, and individual beings are like the spaces in pots. When the pots are destroyed, the spaces in them merge completely into space. In the same way the individual beings merge into the Self." Gaudapada, Mandukya Karika 3.3-4

The space in the pot was never a piece cut off from space. Space cannot be cut. The pot made it look bounded, and when the pot is gone, nothing has to travel anywhere. Gaudapada adds a fine point: when one pot's space is filled with smoke or dust, the others are not, which is why one person's joy and grief are not felt by everyone. Gaudapada, Mandukya Karika 3.5

The rope and the snake

The third picture answers a different question. If I am already the limitless Self, why do I not know it? Why do I so plainly experience myself as a small, anxious creature in a large and dangerous world?

Loading the diagram

Gaudapada again: as a rope that is not clearly made out in the dark is imagined to be a snake or a streak of water, so the Self is imagined to be all sorts of things; and when the rope is known for what it is, the imagining stops. Gaudapada, Mandukya Karika 2.17-18

Three things in this picture repay attention. The snake is not nothing: it is the rope, wrongly seen. The fear it causes is perfectly real, though its object is not. And the cure is not to kill the snake or to run from it. The cure is light. Shankara's word for the mistake is , "superimposition": laying the features of one thing over another. He begins his great commentary by saying that this is what we all do, all the time, when we lay the features of the body and mind over the Self and say "I am tall", "I am sad", "I am dying". The name for not knowing one's own nature is , ignorance.

This explains why, in this school, liberation is said to come by knowledge and not by any action. No action is needed to turn a snake into a rope.

One teaching, three readings

Everything so far has been presented in its simplest and most radical form: the Self simply is Brahman. That is the reading of the Advaita school, and it is the one best known outside India. It is not the only reading. The Upanishads contain passages that stress identity and passages that stress difference, and the great teachers of Vedanta, all commenting on the same texts, drew three main pictures of how the Self and Brahman are related.

Perspectives

How are Atman and Brahman related?

Three schools of Vedanta, three answers. All three accept the same Upanishads as authority.

Advaita

Shankara (traditionally 788-820 CE)

Non-dualism. Brahman alone is ultimately real, and is without qualities or parts. The individual self is not a part or a product of Brahman but Brahman itself, appearing limited through ignorance. The world of many things is an appearance: not sheer nothing, but not what it seems, like the snake in the rope. Liberation is the removal of ignorance by knowledge. "You are that" states a strict identity.

Source: Brahma Sutra Bhashya; Upadeshasahasri

Vishishtadvaita

Ramanuja (traditionally 1017-1137 CE)

Non-duality of a qualified whole. Brahman is the personal Lord, Narayana, possessed of every perfection. Souls and matter are entirely real and eternally distinct from him, yet cannot exist apart from him: they are his body, and he is their inner Self. The soul is to the Lord as a body is to the person who lives in it. Liberation is unbroken loving communion with him, reached through devotion and his grace. "You are that" means: the Lord who is the Self of the universe is also your inmost Self.

Source: Shri Bhashya; Vedartha Sangraha

Dvaita

Madhva (1238-1317 CE)

Dualism. The Lord, Vishnu, alone is independent. Souls and matter are real and depend on him wholly, and the differences between the Lord and the soul, between the Lord and matter, between soul and soul, soul and matter, and one material thing and another, are all real and eternal. The soul resembles the Lord as a reflection resembles its original, and never becomes him. Liberation is the blissful service of the Lord, by his grace. Madhva reads the Chandogya sentence so as to mean "you are not that", or takes it to express likeness and dependence.

Source: Anuvyakhyana; Vishnu Tattva Vinirnaya

Go back to the three pictures with this in mind, because each school reads them. For Shankara the salt shows that Brahman is the single reality of everything. For Ramanuja it shows the Lord pervading all things as their inner Self, while salt remains salt and water remains water. The pot and the rope belong especially to Advaita, and the other schools argue against them: a real world, they say, cannot be compared to an illusion.

There are further schools between and beside these three, among them those of Nimbarka, Vallabha and Chaitanya, each with its own account. They belong to a later phase of this site.

In short

Key takeaways

  • Brahman is the unchanging ground of the whole universe. Atman is the unchanging Self, the witness within. The central teaching of the Upanishads is that the two are not separate.
  • Four "great sayings" state this, the best known being "You are that" (Chandogya Upanishad 6.8.7).
  • Salt dissolved in water shows a reality present everywhere though unseen. The space in a pot shows how the one Self can seem to be many. The rope taken for a snake shows how ignorance makes us misread what we are.
  • Advaita holds that the Self is identical with Brahman; Vishishtadvaita that souls are real and form the body of the Lord; Dvaita that the soul and the Lord are eternally distinct. All three rest on the same texts.

Sources

References

Primary texts

  • Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 1.4.10, 2.3.6, 3.4.2; Chandogya Upanishad 6.8.7, 6.13; Taittiriya Upanishad 2.1, 3.1; Aitareya Upanishad 3.3; Mandukya Upanishad 2. Translation: Patrick Olivelle, The Early Upanishads: Annotated Text and Translation (Oxford University Press, 1998).
  • Gaudapada, Mandukya Karika 2.17-18, 3.3-5. Translation: Swami Nikhilananda, The Mandukyopanishad with Gaudapada's Karika and Shankara's Commentary (Sri Ramakrishna Ashrama, Mysore, 1936).
  • Shankara, Brahma Sutra Bhashya, introduction (Adhyasa Bhashya). Translation: Swami Gambhirananda, Brahma-Sutra-Bhashya of Sri Shankaracharya (Advaita Ashrama, 1965).
  • Ramanuja, Shri Bhashya. Translation: George Thibaut, The Vedanta-Sutras with the Commentary by Ramanuja, Sacred Books of the East, vol. 48 (Clarendon Press, 1904).
  • Ramanuja, Vedartha Sangraha. Translation: S. S. Raghavachar, Vedartha-Sangraha of Sri Ramanujacharya (Sri Ramakrishna Ashrama, Mysore, 1956).
  • Madhva, Vishnu Tattva Vinirnaya. Translation: S. S. Raghavachar, Srimad Vishnu-Tattva-Vinirnaya of Sri Madhvacharya (Sri Ramakrishna Ashrama, Mangalore, 1959).

Studies

  • Eliot Deutsch, Advaita Vedanta: A Philosophical Reconstruction (University of Hawaii Press, 1969).
  • John Braisted Carman, The Theology of Ramanuja: An Essay in Interreligious Understanding (Yale University Press, 1974).
  • B. N. K. Sharma, Philosophy of Sri Madhvacharya (Motilal Banarsidass, 1986).
  • Deepak Sarma, An Introduction to Madhva Vedanta (Ashgate, 2003).
  • Surendranath Dasgupta, A History of Indian Philosophy, 5 vols. (Cambridge University Press, 1922-1955), volumes 1, 3 and 4.
  • Andrew J. Nicholson, Unifying Hinduism: Philosophy and Intellectual History (Columbia University Press, 2010).