Skip to content
Ekam Sat

Section III: Core Ideas

Karma and Samsara

Action and its consequences, rebirth, and why karma is not fate.

A word that travelled badly

Few Sanskrit words are as widely used as "karma", and few are as widely misused. In everyday English it has come to mean a cosmic payback: you were rude to a waiter, you spilled coffee on yourself, that's karma. Or it means fate: "it's my karma", said with a shrug.

Neither is what the tradition teaches. To see what it does teach, begin with the plain meaning of the word.

Karma means action

comes from the root kri, "to do". It means action, a deed. In the oldest texts it means in particular the ritual act. The Upanishads widen it to every deliberate act of body, speech and mind, and state the principle in a sentence:

As a person acts, as a person behaves, so that person becomes. By good action one becomes good, by bad action bad.

Look carefully at what is being claimed. It is not that someone watches your actions and hands out rewards. It is that an action is not finished when it is done. It goes on working: in the world, as consequences, and in the person who did it, as character. Every act of generosity makes the next one easier. Every lie makes the next lie easier. We are, in a quite literal sense, built by what we do.

Karma, then, names both halves of a single thing: the deed and the result that grows out of it. The result is called its , its fruit. The image is deliberate. A fruit is not a prize awarded to a seed. It is what the seed becomes.

Three kinds of karma

If actions bear fruit, an obvious difficulty arises. Results do not always follow at once. Honest people suffer and scoundrels prosper. The tradition's answer is that fruits ripen at different times, some in this life and some in another, and on that basis it sorts karma into three kinds.

, "heaped up", is the entire store of results from past action that has not yet begun to bear fruit. , "begun", is the part of that store which has started to ripen and has produced this present life: this body, these parents, this span of years, these basic circumstances. , "coming", is what is being created now by present action. It is also called , "being done".

Teachers of Vedanta explain the three with the image of an archer.

Loading the diagram

The quiver on the archer's back is sanchita: many arrows, not yet shot. The arrow already flying is prarabdha: it has left the bow, and nothing the archer does now will bring it back. The arrow on the string is agami: it has not yet been released, and where it goes is the archer's choice.

Why karma is not fatalism

The archer makes the central point about freedom, and it is worth stating slowly.

Your past has given you a starting position. You did not choose your body, your family or your century, and the tradition says these are the fruit of what you did before. That much is fixed. It is the arrow in flight.

But the past does not act for you. In this moment you are holding the bow. What you do with the situation you are in is fresh action, and it is yours.

The texts press this hard, because the lazy conclusion, "everything is fated, so why try?", was evidently as tempting then as now. The Yoga Vasishtha devotes several chapters to it and concludes that what people call fate is nothing other than their own past effort, and that present effort, if it is stronger, overcomes it. Yoga Vasishtha, Mumukshu Prakarana 2.4-9 The Mahabharata puts it in a farmer's image: destiny is the seed and human effort is the field, and a seed with no field to grow in comes to nothing. Mahabharata, Anushasana Parva 6

The two words to remember are , what comes to you from the past, and , what you do about it. Life is always both.

Samsara: the wandering

Follow the logic one step further. If every action must bear fruit, and one lifetime is plainly too short for all of it to ripen, then the story cannot end at death. The store of unripened karma requires another life in which to ripen. In that life new actions are done, which lay up new results, which require another life. This endless round is , literally "wandering on".

The Bhagavad Gita compares it to changing clothes: as a person puts aside worn-out garments and takes new ones, so the embodied self puts aside worn-out bodies and takes new ones. An older image, from the Upanishads, is the caterpillar that reaches the tip of a blade of grass and draws itself across to the next. Bhagavad Gita 2.22; Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 4.4.3

What is it that goes on?

The physical body obviously does not. It is burned or buried. What continues, according to the tradition, is the , the "subtle body": the mind, the powers of sense and action, and the vital energies, together with everything that past experience has left in them.

What it carries is described with two words. A is an impression, the trace that an act or an experience leaves in the mind. A is a tendency, what many impressions of the same kind add up to. The word vasana also means a lingering scent, and the Gita uses exactly that picture: the self takes these along when it leaves a body "as the wind carries scents from their source". Bhagavad Gita 15.8

This is how the tradition accounts for something every parent notices: children arrive with temperaments. One is fearless, one cautious; one is drawn to music before anyone has taught her. On this view a newborn is not a blank page but a traveller with luggage.

The Yoga Sutra states the mechanism in two short lines: the store of karma has its root in the afflictions of the mind, and as long as the root remains, it ripens as birth, length of life and experience. Patanjali, Yoga Sutra 2.12-13

Loading the diagram

Acting without being bound

Here the teaching meets a real difficulty. If every action lays up results that must be lived through, and living through them means more action, how could anyone ever get out? Stopping action altogether is no solution. The Gita observes that nobody can remain without acting even for a moment. Bhagavad Gita 3.5 Sitting still is an action. Refusing to choose is a choice.

The Bhagavad Gita's answer is its most famous verse.

Your claim is to the action alone, never to its fruits. Do not make the fruit of action your motive, and do not cling to inaction either.

The verse is often misread as "do not care about results", which would be a recipe for carelessness. Read it in its setting. Arjuna is paralysed before a battle because he is calculating outcomes, and Krishna tells him that the outcome was never his to command. The archer chooses the aim and the release. Wind, distance and the movement of the target are not his.

What is asked is a shift in where the mind rests. Do the work completely, with full skill and care, as an offering. Then let go of the claim on what comes of it. The next verses call this evenness of mind in success and failure "yoga", and add that yoga is "skill in action". Bhagavad Gita 2.48, 2.50

This is , action without craving. Its point is practical. What binds is not the action but the grasping that goes with it: "I did this, and I must have that." Take away the grasping and the same action leaves no hook in the mind. The Gita says such a person is untouched by wrong "as a lotus leaf is untouched by water". Bhagavad Gita 5.10

How does karma actually work?

There is a puzzle in all this that the philosophers saw clearly. An action is over in a moment. Its fruit may come years later, or lifetimes later. What connects the two across the gap? The schools gave different answers.

Perspectives

What carries an action to its result?

Three classical answers to the same question.

Mimamsa

Jaimini, Shabara, Kumarila

A rightly performed act produces an unseen potency, called , "what was not there before". It persists after the act is over and in due time delivers the result. No god is needed to administer it. The act itself, through this potency, is enough.

Source: Shabara Bhashya on Mimamsa Sutra 2.1.5

Nyaya and Vaisheshika

Gautama, Kanada and their commentators

Action leaves an invisible quality in the self, called , "the unseen", as merit or demerit. Being unconscious, it cannot arrange its own results, so an intelligent , the Lord, directs the process.

Source: Nyaya Sutra 4.1.19-21; Vaisheshika Sutra 5.2

Vedanta

Badarayana, with Shankara and Ramanuja

"The fruit comes from him, for that is reasonable." The sutras record the Mimamsa view by name and reject it: an action that has ceased, or an unconscious potency, cannot produce a fitting result at a later time. The Lord gives the fruit, in exact accordance with what each has done.

Source: Brahma Sutra 3.2.38-41

These are disagreements about the machinery. On the main point, that action shapes the future of the one who acts, all three agree.

Two neighbouring traditions

Karma and rebirth are not the property of Hinduism alone. Buddhism and Jainism, which arose in the same world, teach both, and each understands them in its own way.

The Buddha located karma in intention: "It is intention that I call karma; having intended, one acts by body, speech and mind." Anguttara Nikaya 6.63 Buddhism also teaches rebirth without an unchanging self that is reborn. What continues is a stream of causes and effects, like one flame lighting the next.

Jainism takes the most concrete view. Karma is a kind of very fine matter that flows toward the soul when it acts with passion and clings to it, weighing it down. Liberation comes from stopping the inflow and wearing away what has already stuck, which is why Jain practice stresses non-violence and austerity so strongly. Umasvati, Tattvartha Sutra, chapters 6 and 8

Moksha: freedom from the wheel

Samsara has no natural end. A good life leads to a better birth, and a better birth is still a birth, with ageing and death in it. So the final aim cannot be a better place on the wheel. It is to be free of the wheel. That freedom is .

How it comes about is the subject of the next lessons, and the schools describe it differently. The outline as Vedanta gives it is this. When a person comes to know the true nature of the Self, the stored karma is destroyed, "as a blazing fire turns firewood to ash". New action no longer clings. Only the karma that has already begun continues, like the arrow in flight, until the body falls. Then there is no return. Bhagavad Gita 4.37; Brahma Sutra 4.1.13-15, 4.1.19 A person in that last condition, free but still living, is called a .

For the devotional schools the decisive thing is not knowledge alone but the grace of the Lord, received through loving surrender. Both will be met again.

In short

Key takeaways

  • Karma means action, together with the result that grows from it. It is not fate, not punishment and not the verdict of a partial judge.
  • There are three kinds: sanchita (the stored), prarabdha (what has begun and produced this life) and agami (what is being made now). The archer's quiver, flying arrow and drawn arrow picture them.
  • The past sets the starting point; present effort is free. The texts explicitly reject fatalism.
  • Samsara is the cycle of rebirth that unripened karma requires. The subtle body carries impressions and tendencies from life to life.
  • Action done without clinging to its results does not bind (Gita 2.47). Moksha is freedom from the cycle altogether.
  • Mimamsa, Nyaya-Vaisheshika and Vedanta explain differently how an action reaches its result. Buddhism and Jainism share the idea of karma and understand it in their own ways.

Sources

References

Primary texts

  • Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 4.4.3, 4.4.5. Translation: Patrick Olivelle, The Early Upanishads: Annotated Text and Translation (Oxford University Press, 1998).
  • Bhagavad Gita 2.22, 2.47-50, 3.5, 4.37, 5.10, 15.8, with the commentary of Shankara on 13.23. Translation: Swami Gambhirananda, Bhagavad Gita with the Commentary of Shankaracharya (Advaita Ashrama, 1984).
  • Brahma Sutra 2.1.34, 3.2.38-41, 4.1.13-15, 4.1.19, with the commentary of Shankara. Translation: Swami Gambhirananda, Brahma-Sutra-Bhashya of Sri Shankaracharya (Advaita Ashrama, 1965).
  • Patanjali, Yoga Sutra 2.12-13. Translation: Edwin F. Bryant, The Yoga Sutras of Patanjali (North Point Press, 2009).
  • Yoga Vasishtha, Mumukshu Prakarana 2.4-9.
  • Mahabharata, Anushasana Parva, chapter 6.
  • Mimamsa Sutra 2.1.5 with the commentary of Shabara; Nyaya Sutra 4.1.19-21; Vaisheshika Sutra 5.2.
  • Anguttara Nikaya 6.63. Translation: Bhikkhu Bodhi, The Numerical Discourses of the Buddha (Wisdom Publications, 2012).
  • Umasvati, Tattvartha Sutra, chapters 6 and 8. Translation: Nathmal Tatia, That Which Is: Tattvartha Sutra (HarperCollins, 1994).

Studies

  • Wendy Doniger O'Flaherty (ed.), Karma and Rebirth in Classical Indian Traditions (University of California Press, 1980).
  • Wilhelm Halbfass, Tradition and Reflection: Explorations in Indian Thought (State University of New York Press, 1991), chapter 9, on karma, apurva and causality.
  • Bruce R. Reichenbach, The Law of Karma: A Philosophical Study (University of Hawaii Press, 1990).
  • Padmanabh S. Jaini, The Jaina Path of Purification (University of California Press, 1979).